When do prop rules end the account?
Simulation: October 27, 2026 · Updated: October 28, 2026
Summary
1,899 rule scenarios were simulated across 41 programs from 9 prop firms. In the 708 scenarios where a rule kicked in, 59.6% ended the account; the other 40.4% ended in a warning, a blocked order, a closed position or wiped profit.
The max loss rule ended the account in 41 of 41 programs, the daily loss rule in 36 of 41. The news rule reacted in 22 programs but ended the account in only 10; elsewhere it wiped profit, counted a soft breach or warned.
These are not real trader statistics: the scenarios are tests that break rules on purpose. The numbers show how strict each rule is, not which rule gets broken most often.
What happens when a rule kicks in?
Outcome of all scenarios. "No effect" rows are control scenarios or rules the program doesn't have (e.g. opening a hedge where hedging is allowed).
- Account ends42222.2%
- Profit wiped512.7%
- Position closed321.7%
- Order / pass blocked784.1%
- Soft breach counted231.2%
- Warning1025.4%
- No effect1,19162.7%
By phase
Challenge (phase 1), verification (phases 2 and 3), funded account and instant funding programs. Wiped profit and closed positions are more common on funded accounts: most firms apply news and weekend rules only there.
Rule by rule
Each row is a rule type. "Account ends" shows in how many of the tested programs a violation ended the account; the bar is the outcome mix across all of that rule's scenarios. Tap a row to see the mix.
Max loss (static / trailing)41 / 41
- Account ends 96
Programs that react: 41 / 41
Daily loss limit36 / 41
- Account ends 85
- Position closed 7
- No effect 7
Programs that react: 39 / 41
Minimum hold time / HFT34 / 41
- Account ends 82
- No effect 106
Programs that react: 34 / 41
Time limit / inactivity20 / 41
- Account ends 49
- No effect 63
Programs that react: 20 / 41
Hedging14 / 41
- Account ends 39
- Warning 10
- No effect 75
Programs that react: 18 / 41
News window10 / 40
- Account ends 26
- Profit wiped 30
- Soft breach counted 9
- Warning 7
- No effect 109
Programs that react: 22 / 40
Market open / gap8 / 24
- Account ends 18
- Order / pass blocked 3
- No effect 36
Programs that react: 9 / 24
All-in (one trade risking the limit)5 / 29
- Account ends 15
- Order / pass blocked 3
- Soft breach counted 5
- Warning 30
- No effect 24
Programs that react: 24 / 29
Weekend holding6 / 40
- Account ends 6
- Position closed 8
- No effect 80
Programs that react: 13 / 40
Total / per-symbol open risk4 / 40
- Account ends 4
- Profit wiped 4
- Position closed 7
- Order / pass blocked 3
- No effect 72
Programs that react: 10 / 40
Risk per trade1 / 28
- Account ends 2
- Warning 4
- No effect 52
Programs that react: 2 / 28
Order bursts / bulk entries0 / 29
- Soft breach counted 9
- Warning 25
- No effect 51
Programs that react: 12 / 29
Max lot size0 / 33
- Order / pass blocked 30
- No effect 60
Programs that react: 8 / 33
Minimum trading days0 / 13
- Order / pass blocked 22
- No effect 8
Programs that react: 12 / 13
Daily profit cap0 / 23
- Profit wiped 17
- Position closed 3
- Order / pass blocked 1
- No effect 34
Programs that react: 8 / 23
Martingale / averaging down0 / 25
- Warning 17
- No effect 98
Programs that react: 4 / 25
Trades per day0 / 33
- Warning 9
- No effect 70
Programs that react: 4 / 33
Overnight holding / end-of-day close0 / 36
- Position closed 7
- No effect 78
Programs that react: 6 / 36
Allowed symbol list0 / 5
- Order / pass blocked 7
Programs that react: 5 / 5
Open positions at once0 / 28
- Order / pass blocked 6
- No effect 59
Programs that react: 3 / 28
Best day (consistency)0 / 3
- Order / pass blocked 3
Programs that react: 3 / 3
Method
- Simulator: the site's backtest engine (order book plus prop rule layer) ran on real price data with rules read from the firms' websites. Every program was tested in every phase separately.
- Scenarios: at least one deliberate violation per rule (e.g. a loss past the daily limit, opening a trade inside a news window) and, for most rules, a control scenario (a similar trade that stays within the rule). The outcome is what the program's written rule says happens.
- Scope: 9 firms, 41 programs, 23 rule types, 1,899 scenarios. The engine's own internal tests and 9 scenarios that couldn't be set up are excluded. Every scenario produced its expected outcome.
- Not tested: 7 rule groups are outside the simulator (leverage / margin, payout conditions, EA / copy trading, bans without a published threshold). They are not in the table.
Limits
- This page contains no real trader data. It doesn't show why any real account failed, and it can't tell you which rule gets broken most often.
- The number of scenarios varies by rule (some rules were tested with more variations). Read the percentages as how strict a rule is, not how often it happens.
- Firm rules change. The simulation used the rules in effect on the date above; read the firm's current rules before you trade.
Test your strategy under prop rules
Pick a prop program in Backtest; daily loss, max loss, news and the other rules are checked live as you open trades.
Simulation results, not real trading results. No profit promise. Not investment advice.